I was enchanted by this book--by the dreamy quality of Rose's world (I was reminded of Ann Patchett, The Magician's Assistant in particular), by her tragic and mysterious brother, and by her precocious (think Holden Caulfield) ability to perceive the most hidden nuances of the adult world around her.
I checked out a few online reviews and discovered that many people don't like this book. They found it vague, unfinished. They hated the lack of quotation marks. Is it odd that I never noticed, for one moment, the punctuation in this work?
It was repeatedly described as being about how hard it is to love our families when we know them too well. I didn't perceive that as the theme at all! I thought Bender was exploring the mysteries of talent, of how our gifts are both blessings and terrible burdens--how they can frighten us into paralysis (Rose's father), separate us from each other (her brother, Joe), but ultimately lead us to our own particular destinies. I also felt it looked into the struggles of those who don't know how to find or use their gifts, and the havoc they can wreak as they struggle for direction--Rose's mother being the case in point.
Anyway, I didn't have a week of reading, but I did enjoy one lovely, haunting book! The rest of the time, I gazed off into the distance and thought about nothing. Which of course, is what I do most of the time.
11 comments:
It's nice to find a book that fits perfectly with whatever mood has struck you. Thanks for writing about this one. Staring off into the distance sounds pretty nice.
you should leave a review so the author knows that someone "got" what she was trying to say.
i just spent 10 days reading "gone with the wind" and liked and hated it at the same time. i've never seen the movie, so i think i'd like to give it a go so i can say "oh, that's not right" or "hmm, i see why they did that...." and annoy the people who watch the movie with me.
"Loved and hated it at the same time" is a perfect evaluation of GWTW. I felt the same.
i loved your review.
staring off into the distance and thinking about nothing sounds wonderful. sometimes it is so nice to give the brain a rest.
next week is my vacation. i can not wait to get away from my job. that in itself is a vacation.
I read GWTW years ago and pretty much had a love hate thing as well.
Verb, the book you read sounds interesting. I'll look for it.
Staring off into the distance and thinking about nothing sounds good. Every now again I feel the urge and do. Does give the brain a rest. :)
My vacation ends August 17th. :(
holden caufield needed a good slap and sending to bed with no tea
Heck yeah, he did.
And I never decided--was he totally nuts and most of that stuff didn't actually happen? Or was he telling the truth?
I read GWTW when I was 11 and loved it but I haven't read it since. I suspect that if I'd read it older, I would hate it.
verb, i saw a special today about this group and thought you'd like them too http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=100000396833446#!/pages/The-Naming-Project/147159482015423?sk=wall
it's for a group called 'the naming project' and i wish they had an east coast branch, i'd volunteer
Thanks, Jilly. I'll check it out!
I did notice the "no quotation mark" thing, but I kind of liked it.
The only thing about the book I didn't like was the brother thing...I liked her relationship with him, I just didn't get exactly what he did...what his gift was.
I want to read Aimee Bender's other books now.
Post a Comment